Gear Review: Thrift Store Dress Shirt

At the end of the Northern New Mexico Loop in 2019.

Since moving out West in 1999,  I have discovered the importance of protection from the harsh UV radiation found at elevation.

Due to my gene pool, I tan very well (Thanks, distant ancestors who invaded southern Italy! 🙂  ). However,  NO ONE truly tans well at 10,000+ feet.

The sun destroys the skin at best and can cause cancer at worst. Not good.

The solutions are simple: Slather yourself up with sunscreen or wear the appropriate clothing.

I’m not too fond of sunscreen for extended trips except for my nose and cheekbones. . Esp on backpacking trips, the sunscreen clogs the pores, collects dirt, gives an “unclean” feeling, runs into your eyes,  is extra to pack, and is just plain messy.

So my choice for sun protection is clothing — a wide-brimmed hat to cover the face and a long-sleeved shirt. The rolled-down sleeves cover the arms, and the collar protects the neck paired with the hat.

In the non-humid climates, I tend to hike in; the long sleeves keep me cooler by making a micro-climate. Naturally, long sleeves help with bug protection too. A button-down shirt lets you roll up the sleeves as needed and unbutton the shirt for added ventilation.

Now, you can buy plenty of long sleeve shirts made for hiking, travel, and sun protection. They are sharp-looking, of high quality, and make you look like you stepped out of a gear catalog or a safari.   They can be  $65+ each as well.

Really stylish sun protection!

But on any extended backpacking trip, you are beating the crap out of your shirts. They get perma-stains between the combined forces of the pack straps, salt from sweat, and dirt.

A $65shirt may still be usable at the end of 4+ months of backpacking, but it will look like, to use a technical term, crap.

Being a self-proclaimed dirt bagger with a practical bent,  I can’t see why I’d want to spend $65+ on a shirt that will look like a thrift store shirt at the end of the trip.

So what to do? Buy the hiking shirt from the thrift or a discount store, to begin with! 🙂

If I attached a gold necklace to my compass, this shirt would rock!

My shirts of choice are the old polycotton blend dress shirts or Western snap shirts ubiquitous in any thrift store.

For the princely sum of $10 I achieved the desired sun and bug protection. Or I’ll raid my closet for old shirts!

In Comb Ridge. PCO Joan West.

Yes, there is cotton in these shirts, but the thin fabric does dry quickly. If it does get cold and rainy, I change into a thermal anyway, regardless of the shirt, I am wearing.

I also find these shirts very comfortable, breathe better, and feel less clammy than a “technical” shirt or a nylon button-down for three-season use. I’ve tried the so-called hiking or traveling shirts and prefer the cotton-blend ones. And many of the “real” hiking shirts make me look like a reject from an Indiana Jones cosplay convention.

What about longevity? Not only have these shirts lasted me the length of a thru-hike, but they were serviceable enough to wear AFTER a thru-hike too. The only reason why I discarded the shirts are that there is a fine line between being a dirt bagger and looking homeless. The shirt was structurally sound; they just seemed a little, ah, worn. The shirt only had to go after a while. ( Esp after being married. 😉 )

Now, there are times when it makes more sense to wear the more expensive shirts. It pays to be a little more presentable if the trip is more of a  cultural journey and less backcountry-oriented. No reason to be a literal Ugly American. 🙂

Guiding in Yosemite with Brian Robinson. The trip participants thought my Wrangler snap-button shirt looked stylish! ) Photo courtesy of Beth K.

If I represent a group or a person or earn pay for my services, perhaps the thrift store shirt is not the best choice.

Otherwise? I’ll buy a thrift store special. For $10, I can beat it up, make it dirty, have it full of sweat, and it will take a lickin’.

As mentioned, I will recycle old “casual” dress shirts from my closet, too. These shirts look good enough to wear outside of hiking and meet the critical non-dirt-bagger approval! 😉

And since 2015 or so?

The classic plaid Western snap style shirts of 65/35 polycotton blend are ones I’ve gravitated to in recent years. Even new, I’ve found them for $30 or less in stores in “farm and ranch” type stores or Wally World.

And specifically, here’s a 60/40 polycotton blend for $30. In my experience, the 5% difference does not matter! And the extra $5 might save you a trip to the store. 😉

I’ll put the $75 I saved for more important things. Like a post-trip burger and beer!

Overall summary: A simple shirt that may already be in your closet works well for hiking. Practical, durable, inexpensive, and perhaps preferable to a “real” hiking shirt.

EDIT DEC 2019: A very in-depth science-based post validates my experience in detail. Check it out.

 But I have to say I’m with Paul on this one: for a measly $20 you can get a good-looking hiking shirt that’s lighter, more breathable, and dries faster (or just as fast) as the Kuhl or Montbell at a quarter of the price.    Oh, and it won’t kill you.  

EDIT MAY 2022 – I’ve long thought that a shirt used by ranchers in the hot sun all day works well enough for hiking and sun protection. It turns out that the cut, material, and even the dye help make a shirt that works well. This Stack Exchange thread links to an academic article that puts more numbers on why I like these shirts so much. Along with another report from SkinCancer.org that mentions material and the tightness vs. looseness of clothing.

The short answer is, it varies. The three factors that most influence the UV transmission factor of clothing are kind of obvious:

Material: Some materials are better at absorbing UV than others; for example, the paper cited below suggests that polyester absorbs more UV light (particularly UVB) than cotton.

Weave: The thicker and more tightly woven a piece of fabric is, the less light it lets through.

Color: Dyes work by absorbing various frequencies of visible light, and many of them will absorb UV too. Of course, high light absorption at visible frequencies doesn’t necessarily imply high UV absorption, but as a general rule of thumb, white or lightly colored fabrics do tend to let more UV through than darker fabrics.

In addition, there are also “invisible dyes” that can absorb UV without darkening the visible color of the fabric. Some UV-absorbent laundry additives are sold specifically for that purpose, but many laundry detergents also contain fluorescent compounds called optical brighteners that absorb some UV light and re-emit it in the visible spectrum. Also, getting the fabric wet will change its UV transmittance, typically increasing it.

….

Fit: Loose-fitting apparel is preferable. Tight clothing can stretch and reduce the level of protection offered, as the fibers pull away from each other and allow more UV light to pass through.

What doe all this mean? A loose-fitting shirt that breathes well with polyester, the right weave, and reinforced in the shoulder and collar that’s against the skin tightly vs. the rest of the shirt makes a great shirt. Almost like those people out in the sun, all day knew something ???? 😉

In the Uncompaghre Plateau

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lee I Joe
Lee I Joe
9 years ago

I have been wearing thrift shop hiking shirts for years. Yes,actual hiking shirts, they aren’t all that hard to find around here as the local fishermen buy lots of L/S Columbia shirts, wear them a few times and discard them.

James of Canada
James of Canada
8 years ago

I prefer 100% poly shirts over poly/cotton but thrift store finds are a matter of time and location, IE you need to go often and what you find depends on what is popular in your area. Wool in pants or shirts is hard to find because the market for them is almost nil. Around here, there is no such thing as a skirt looking “thrift”, in urban areas things get tossed even before the first sign of wear shows. So 95% of what I see at thrift stores looks brand new. In this regard, I find Value Village better than… Read more »

trackback

[…] September wrap-up of his Northern New Mexico Loop trip Paul “PMags” Magnanti mentioned his love for cotton-polyester blend thrift store hiking shirts, particularly western-style snap-button shirts. Having been raised in a “cotton kills” […]